Paul and Mary Ellen Hartwick

Office Phone

Cell Phone

Office Fax

Send Email
Send Text Message

Batavia Office
570 East Main Street
BataviaNY 14020

How Much Is Your Home Worth?
Email Me New Listings

About Me

Paul & Mary Ellen Hartwick

Your 2 for 1 Real Estate Team

Whether you are buying or selling a home, we will give you the attention and service you deserve. We work with people who are buying their first home, downsizing, or relocating across the state, the country, or the world!

Because we work together as a team on all transactions, you have the benefit of two full time real estate professionals working for you!

We believe communication is key to a successful real estate transaction and strive to keep the lines of communication open.


As your real estate agent, we will:

  • Do our homework and provide you with a Comparative Market Analysis to determine the asking price for your home.
  • Assist you with relocation.
  • Give your property exposure on the Internet and in print.
  • List your property on the Multiple Listing Service and, where it can be seen 24/7.
  • Always conduct our business with you and potential buyers in a professional manner.
  • Work diligently to get results.
  • Provide feedback on all showings.
  • Keep you informed with open communication from the time you list through closing.


Whether you are a first-time buyer or an experienced home owner, we will:

  • meet with you to go over every aspect of buying a home in today's real estate market.
  • explain things to you, such as the importance of being a pre-qualified buyer.
  • answer all of your questions. We believe there are no silly or dumb questions. We encourage our buyers to ask questions so they clearly understand the process of buying a  home. 
  • We will create a customized search for your new home based on your individualized criteria.
  • You will be informed of all available homes that match your criteria as soon as they go on the market.


  • Paul grew up in Tonawanda andgraduated from Kenmore East High School.
  •  Mary Ellen grew up in the Stafford-LeRoy area and graduated from LeRoy High School, Class of '71.
  • Paul studied Elementary Education at Midwestern University
  • Mary Ellen majored in English and Humanities at SUNY Alfred, Class of '80 and Human Development & Family Studies at Cornell University, Class of '82.
  • Paul worked with Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation and National Grid for 37 years before entering into his real estate career.
  • Emmy worked at Divi Resorts, Cornell University and Ithaca College.
  • Our management and customer service backgrounds provide us with the business tools and people skills that are needed to provide excellent results for our clients.
  • We have lived in the country and the city and currently live in a historic home in the Village of Alexander.
  • We understand what it is like to move to a new location, whether it is across town, or across the country.

We invite you to contact us. We would like the opportunity to meet with you and learn about your real estate goals  and assist you in meeting them.

Community Activities
  • We are active volunteers in the community, including The Salvation Army and The Museum Quilt Guild.
Communities Served
  • All of Genesee, Orleans, Wyoming Counties
  • Part of Erie, Livingston, Monroe Counties
  • GRAR, Greater Rochester Association of REALTORS®
  • NYSAR, New York State Association of REALTORS®
  • NAR, National Association of REALTORS®

  • First-time Homebuyers, Historic, Multi-Family, Relocation, Residential, Rural/Country
My Reviews
  • "Thank you for doing such a great job. Thank you especially for keeping me informed of everything that was happening. It was much appreciated!”
    -Chris Miller, East Aurora, NY
  • “Paul and Emmy are great. They helped us to find our first home and it turned out to be our dream house. They helped us every step of the way.”
    -David and Tereza Arnetova Panzone
  • “Emmy and Paul made our experience of selling our house a much easier experience than we anticipated. We recommend them to anyone.”
  • “Both Paul and Emmy were the best. They always answered our questions in a timely manner. We have been recommending them to anyone we know that is looking to buy or sell. Thank you Paul and Emmy for a wonderful house-buying experience.”
    -Gus Miller, Perry, NY
  • "Thank you for selling my home. You were always there for me. When my contract ended with another real estate company, -- and I had expected to sign with them again, -- I received a post card from Paul & Emmy at Nothnagle Realtors. I called you and made an appointment. Best thing I could have done. Thank you again for working so hard for me. I appreciate the both of you -- so much." Sincerely,
    -Linda Welch, Perry, New York."
  • "They went the extra mile, even though it is a rough market. . . . I am thankful for all their advice."
    -Rose Jamalkowski, Utah
  • "Paul and Emmy provided all the information we needed and were always available and responded quickly to our calls and questions. They were there for us."
    - Ben & Sharon Dutton, Batavia, NY
  • "Emmy was very sweet and after just a few days I had her number memorized. She was extremely helpful in all areas in giving us all the information we needed for a very fast sale. Paul was also wonderful in his easy manner of explaining all the details in the agreement and financial aspects of the sale. I would highly recommend them to my friends. Thanks so much you two! We ae so happy with our new home!"
    -Michael LaVarnway and Maurietta R. Fountain
  • "It was a great experience for us. Paul and Emmy made buying our home fun and easy. They kepy us well informed and helped us understand the process!"
    -Timothy and Katelyn Draper Leroy, NY
  • "Very honest and trustworthy. Good people to work with." -Dan Schmidt, Wyoming, NY
  • "I greatly appreciate your patience with this sale and your support through the challenges that I faced. I am so thankful that this process is over so I can move on with my life." -Vicki Roberts Byron, NY
  • "The whole experience went fairly smoothly from the beginning. Paul and Emmy made it easy. Thank you!" -Eleanor Scott, Leroy, NY
  • "If we would ever be in need of a Realtor in the future, The 2 for 1 Team would be the only 1 for the 2 of us. Their balance of professionalism and ability to make you feel very comfortable is second to none. They personally showed our home each and every time. They both were there at our open houses. This was very reassuring knowing they were both looking after our home. Paul and Emmy made what could have been a very stressful process a lot easier. We started with 2 representatives and ended up with 2 friends and a lovely new home. In our opinion, you will never find a more customer focused and caring couple in Real Estate. Thank you so much!" -R & R Hodges
Phone: 585.409.2118
Cell: 585.356.1694
Fax: 585.343.8502
Batavia Office
Send Email
Send Text Message
Batavia Office
570 East Main Street
Batavia, NY  14020
Mary Ellen Hartwick, Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

See Us On Facebook Follow us on Twitter See us on LinkedIn See Us on YouTube Red our blog
Our Sponsors
Questions/Comments | Website Feedback | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Site Map
© 1995-2017 Nothnagle REALTORS® Rochester, New York
Website developed and hosted by Independent Broker Advantage Systems, LLC