Charlene Lally of The Lally Team

"Spouses Selling Houses"

Office Phone

Cell Phone

Office Fax

Send Email
Send Text Message

Henrietta Office
2920 East Henrietta Rd
HenriettaNY 14467

How Much Is Your Home Worth?
Email Me New Listings

Featured Property
Listing Photo
Current Listings
About Me

What Qualities are you looking for in Your Real Estate Consultant?

LISTENING: to every one of your Real Estate Wants & needs is the FIRST step we take with our clients

EVALUATING: your Goals & making a PLAN to bring them to fruition

COMMUNICATING: from the very beginning all the way to the closing table with all parties involved. We want your phone call & we strive to be available on YOUR schedule.

RESULTS: I invite you to take a moment to Read what our past clients have said about how their experience was with us & how they got RESULTS that exceeded their expectations.


Our Dedication to our Sellers is to 100% Market your Property in Every way possible to Procure a Ready, Willing & able Buyer. We Pride Ourselves on Being Involved 100% From the Start to the very End of the Sale.  We are Passionate on Giving the Best Advice Possible to Help Aid in the Most Profitable & Stress-Free Process. 

Our Devotion to our buyers is to turn your Wants, Needs & Dreams into a Reality.  We absolutely Love Working with Buyers to Find their Perfect Home!  We Enjoy Guiding, Teaching & Taking care of all the Details in the Transaction so that our Clients can Enjoy the Home Buying Process. 

Using Strong Negotiation tactics on Behalf of our clients has saved them valuable time & money

What Sets us apart from the rest of the real estate crowd?

As a Team, we have the ability to leverage our time & knowledge.  We want our clients to know that they are our Top Priority.

We don’t just disappear after the closing; Our Goal is to be your Real estate consultant for LIFE.  We take pride in keeping in contact with all of our clients to see how they are doing even after their move.

I invite you to contact us for your one-on-one Consultation

**2014 Bronze Award winner

**Rookies of the year Award Winner 

**2015 Platinum Award Winner

** 2016 Platinum Award Winner     

** 2016 GRAR Salesmaster Award Winner                                                                                                                                                            



  • Greater Rochester Association of REALTORS®

  • New York State Association of REALTORS®

  • National Association of REALTORS®

  • Young REALTORS® Network

  • Serves on assessment board of review for Scottsville

Communities Served:

Monroe, Livingston & Ontario County

  • Buyer Agent, Condo/Townhouse, First-time Homebuyers, Investment, Lots/Land, Luxury, New Construction, Relocation, Residential, Short Sales, Single-Family
  • Graduate, REALTOR® Institute
Page 1 of 2 1 | 2 Results per page:
Listing Photo
List Price: $184,900Bedrooms:4
Type: Single-FamilyBaths:2/1
MLS: R1076218
100% Money Back Guarantee
Listing Photo
List Price: $169,900Bedrooms:3
Type: Single-FamilyBaths:1
MLS: R1060282
100% Money Back Guarantee
Listing Photo
List Price: $147,900Bedrooms:4
Type: Single-FamilyBaths:1/1
MLS: R1069532
100% Money Back Guarantee
Listing Photo
List Price: $144,900Bedrooms:4
Type: Single-FamilyBaths:2/1
MLS: R1071962
100% Money Back Guarantee
Listing Photo
List Price: $139,900Bedrooms:3
Type: Single-FamilyBaths:1/1
MLS: R1087133
100% Money Back Guarantee
Listing Photo
List Price: $139,500Bedrooms:3
Type: Single-FamilyBaths:1/1
MLS: R1088459
100% Money Back Guarantee
Open Sunday!
1:00 PM to 3:00 PM
Listing Photo
List Price: $134,900Bedrooms:3
Type: Single-FamilyBaths:1/1
MLS: R1074475
100% Money Back Guarantee
Listing Photo
List Price: $134,900Bedrooms:3
Type: Single-FamilyBaths:1/1
MLS: R1074496
100% Money Back Guarantee
Listing Photo
List Price: $129,900Bedrooms:4
Type: Single-FamilyBaths:2
MLS: R1080444
100% Money Back Guarantee
Listing Photo
List Price: $120,000Bedrooms:4
Type: Single-FamilyBaths:2
MLS: R1078988
100% Money Back Guarantee
Page 1 of 2 1 | 2 Results per page: |

All information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change, or withdrawal. Listings displaying the IDX logo belong to brokers other than Nothnagle REALTORS. Neither the listing broker(s) nor Nothnagle REALTORS shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints, and shall be held totally harmless. © 2017 GENRIS, © 2017 WNYREIS, © 2017 CNYIS, © 2017 CRMLS, © 2017 ECRBR, © 2017 Nothnagle REALTORS. All rights reserved. Listings updated daily.

All information is deemed accurate but not guaranteed. The properties displayed may not be all of the properties available through the Broker Reciprocity Program (IDX Program). Any use of this site other than by potential home buyers or sellers is strictly prohibited. 2017 Elmira-Corning Regional Board of REALTORS®. Listings updated daily.

My Reviews
  • • HAD OUR BEST INTEREST IN MIND "We had our house on the market for 9 months and we were ready to give up before we were contacted by Charlene. We were impressed by her confidence and her assurance that she could get the job done and she did. Within 2 weeks of listing our house she had it sold. She had our best interest in mind through the hold process. We would recommend her and have to anyone looking for a proactive realtor." Tony and Flo D.
  • • DEDICATED "Charlene is a dedicated Real Estate professional. I have experienced her dedication to her clients to serve and succeed! She is a pleasure and asset to the Nothnagle Henrietta Office. Continued successes for you and your clients Charlene." Manager, Abramo Bianchi Nothnagle Henrietta
  • • PREPARED & KNOWLEDGEABLE "I first met Charlene Metz when she solicited for a listing and I was surprised at well prepared and knowledgeable she came. Being so young, and as a former multi-property landlord and a realtor's spouse for many years, I had to ask her how long she had been practicing real estate sales ? She quite honestly and unexpectedly told me "only a few months" After being unable to sell my riverfront lot, which two other experienced brokers and I myself had marketed for over 9 years, Charlene sold the lot in less than three months. She researched all the details and once again did her homework. She personally solicited the eventual buyer, and I could not be happier that I worked with her. I certainly look forward to doing so again and I am sure Charlene will have a very long and successful career." Jack Woods
  • • HAD MY BACK THROUGHOUT THE ENTIRE PROCESS "Charlene was a wonderful resource throughout the whole process! As a first-time seller it can be confusing and frustrating but she was always there with a smile explaining the next steps and the why's and how's of the hoops we jump through and I can honestly say it was worth it. We had a rough patch with some contractors and she was a huge help in getting it resolved. I felt she had our back from day one to close and would recommend her to anyone buying or selling!" -John Burgio
  • • BEST REALTOR I EVER WORKED WITH "I met Charlene at an Open House by chance and I am so glad I did. Charlene was a terrific realtor. She was attentive to my needs, responded to communications quickly, was always very accommodating and managed the paperwork and logistics beautifully. But more than that, she is personable and very easy to work with. This was my fourth house purchase and Charlene is the best realtor I have ever worked with. I would not hesitate to recommend her to anyone looking for a pleasant home buying or selling experience." Amy Merideth
  • • CARED ABOUT OUR NEEDS "My husband and I have just concluded our move into a new home. We can't say enough about what a wonderful experience we had working with your agent, Charlene Metz. From the first time we met her, she was pleasant and interested in what our goals were. After a particularly unpleasant experience with our last realtor (who was not from Nothnagle), we were wary but she quickly put us at ease and made the experience of finding a new home pleasant and fun. The best thing was that we never felt pressured to make a decision. We were close to choosing several homes along the way and then would reject them for reasons that had occurred to us after several days. Charlene never got impatient with us or frustrated. It took us six months and we looked at over 60 different homes (a few on our own at open houses) before making a choice. She spent countless hours showing us houses and helping us find candidates that met our specifications. In the final analysis, we ended up with what we wanted and we thank Charlene Metz for all the help she gave us as we made this major and important decision." Gayle S. Stever, Ph.D. SUNY professor
  • • RECOMMENDED ABOVE ALL OTHERS "Charlene truly is a professional in her field. As a first time home buyer it was an exciting, yet stressful time full of the unknown. Charlene put all my worries and fears to rest. She made the process of buying my first home a great experience and took the extra time to explain all the steps of buying a new home. Charlene also made sure that I had the contacts for the utilities and that I was set-up correctly with them. After the sale of the house was complete, she checked in with me to make sure I was doing well in my new home. I feel that she treated me with genuine respect and caring. Charlene is a realtor I would recommend above all others." -Gina Gray
  • • ATTENTION TO DETAIL "Charlene is an awesome realtor! Her attention to detail is pretty amazing. Always optimistic and upbeat and is helping us through some challenging selling issues. We went through 2 realtors before finding Charlene. I guess the third time is the charm!" -Thomas Coughlan
  • • ENERGETIC, POLITE & ENTHUSIASTIC “Now that Bruce and I are comfortably settled into our new home, we want to thank Charlene for all that she did in helping us sell our cherished home of 42 years and make a smooth transition. From the first time we met this energetic, polite and enthusiastic young lady one day at the Reserve in Brighton, she made a lasting impression. At that time we were just looking at prospective houses, and we happened to meet Charlene. A few weeks later, when we decided that we might consider selling the house, I called Charlene, and she immediately responded to my call. She came to the house and explained all the real estate legalities, conditions, and terms for sellers. She helped us set a reasonable price on the house, and she kept in constant touch. Whenever I had a question, she always promptly responded. She helped us ready the house for sale with a minimum of difficulty, and she personally arranged for any modifications that were needed. She was a gracious hostess at the Open House, and she reported back to us quickly and forthrightly. And miracle of miracles, the house sold in two and a half weeks because Charlene was there at every juncture and was helpful to both the prospective buyers and to us, the sellers. Bruce and I are happy to consider Charlene a personal friend whom we would highly recommend to any of our friends who are considering moving.” -Roz and Bruce
  • • WE FOUND THE PERFECT FIRST HOME & COULDN'T HAVE DONE IT WITHOUT CHARLENE "My fiancé and I serendipitously found Charlene at an open house. We were the last ones to show up and she spent about half an hour talking to us and getting to know what we were looking for in a house. As first time home buyers we went in to the entire process blind, but from our first interaction with Charlene at the open house right up through closing, she guided and informed us, making sure we had all our questions answered. Charlene worked with us to schedule showings (often five in a row!) and was generous with her time, never rushing us. She was great when it came time to make and offer and then as we continued through the negotiation process. We felt secure with Charlene as our realtor and would definitely recommend her to others. We found the perfect first home for us and couldn't have done it without Charlene!" Best, Melissa
  • • CHARLENE CLEARLY HAS THE BEST INTREST OF HER CLIENT IN MIND THE WHOLE TIME "Charlene was a pleasure to work with. My wife and I were having difficulty narrowing down the area of town we wanted to reside in. Charlene was very patient with us, and provided plenty of options and education regarding available homes and their surrounding areas. She was such an asset in helping us narrow our decision. Her diligence did not cease until the sale was closed on the perfect home for us. Any time we had an issue or question arise, we felt free to contact our realtor, with the confidence that we would receive a rapid and accurate response. Charlene clearly has the best interest of her client in mind at all times. Not only did Charlene place us in a great home, she also sold our existing property, which presented many challenges for the selling agent. Several unpredictable circumstances arose during the selling process. Charlene’s persistence, flexibility, and knowledge of the current market made the sale a success. For my future real estate needs, I will certainly call Charlene Metz." -Phillip Ruffo
  • • CHARLENE WAS EXTREMELY HELPFUL"Charlene helped us to find our perfect first home. When we first decided to buy a home, we weren't sure just where to start. We found Charlene after reviewing what everyone else had to say about her and decided to give her a try. From the very beginning she was extremely helpful and answered all the questions we had. She listened to what we wanted and guided us as we went to our many showings. She was there whenever we needed her and worked with our schedule for all showings. We never felt rushed and always felt like she had our best interests in mind. Working with her was a pleasure and it honestly made our first time buying a home very smooth. I would highly recommend her to anyone else who is looking for a realtor." -- Brittany M & Nicholas A
  • • WE FELT COMFORTABLE WITH CHARLENE "We had a great experience with Charlene. She stayed in contact all the way to the end. We both felt so comfortable with her and her ability to get things done. Not only did we find a great realtor, but a new friend. We will recommend Charlene to anyone looking to buy or sell. Thank you from the bottom of our hearts. Good luck in your future endeavors and Marriage. Please keep in touch. God Bless you."
  • • CHARLENE HAD THE PERFECT BALENCE BETWEEN PROVIDING EXPERTISE & LISTENING TO WHAT I WANTED" "Charlene was an immense help and source of information from the beginning stages of the home-buying process. I met Charlene at the very first open house I attended. I didn't have an agent at the time, but immediately felt comfortable asking some of the numerous questions I had. Charlene took the time to sit down with me and explain the sequence of steps and timeline involved. She is always professional, very knowledgeable, and is extremely dedicated. It can be hard to find time when working fill-time, but Charlene was more than accommodating in scheduling visits at times that were convenient for me. She quickly gained a sense of what I was looking for and gave suggestions that fit the home I envisioned. I felt that Charlene had the perfect balance between providing her own expertise and insight, while listening to what I wanted. I was always impressed by how quick and efficient her responses were. Even after the sale Charlene has provided me with references for reputable professionals who can complete work and services on my new home. I couldn't be happier with my experience!" Kaitlin Bates.
  • • CHARLENE IS HELPFUL,TRUSTWORTHY & AN ETHICAL PROFESSIONAL "We highly recommend that you hire Charlene as your real estate professional! She is a helpful, trustworthy, and an ethical professional who is also pleasant to be with. (Important if you're spending lots of time house hunting!) She answered all of our questions in a prompt and professional manner. As first-time home-buyers, we had some apprehension about the entire process and Charlene guided us every step of the way. She has really mastered the balance of listening to what we want and honoring what we were looking for while providing us the support we needed as "newbies" to rest estate game. Even though we felt like we were driving her crazy at times with our high maintenance ways, she was always cheerful, polite, positive, and overall, enthusiastic! We couldn't be happier with our final choice. Thanks, Charlene!" Mr. & Mrs. Rainbow
  • CHARLENE IS AVAILABLE & ATTENTIVE TO HER CLIENTS "Charlene came highly recommended to me by a friend, and I wouldn't hesitate to recommend her highly to anyone that I know. Before being introduced to Charlene, I'd been driving around, searching for properties on my own, but without any luck. Charlene was able to focus and concentrate my search on the areas where I wanted to live, and on the properties that were within my budget. Through her "Property Match" e-mails, I was able to preview homes on my computer before seeing them in-person. This saved me hundreds of hours of time, and hundreds of dollars on gasoline. It wasn't long before she helped me find the perfect house that suited my personality, and fit my budget. And for that I will always be grateful. regarding Charlene's availability and attentiveness to her clients: She is always a phone call or text message away.Thank you, Charlene, you're the best!" Robert Dagnolo

Below are some of the properties that successfully sold within the last year (12/11/2016 and 12/11/2017)

Sellers I Have Helped
Chili 18 Brookview Road Single-Family $128,000
Henrietta 18 Butterfly Lane Single-Family $195,000
Henrietta 168 Eagle Pine Way Condo/Townhouse $179,000
Henrietta 1767 Erie Station Road Single-Family $143,000
Henrietta 76 Grangerford Single-Family $126,500
Irondequoit 300 Brockley Road Single-Family $127,000
Irondequoit 111 Ridgeview Drive Single-Family $108,000
Leroy Village 40 South Street Single-Family $108,250
Lima 7505 E. Main Street Single-Family $92,500
Ogden 197 Ogden Center Road Single-Family $133,000
Ogden 2720 Spencerport Road Single-Family $85,000
Ontario 6541 Furnace Road Single-Family $142,000
Perinton 595 Macedon Center Road Single-Family $249,900
Rochester 48 Camden Street Single-Family $105,000
Rochester 166 Mildorf Street Single-Family $97,500
Rush 812 Stoney Brook Road Single-Family $175,000
Buyers I Have Helped
Brighton 40 Montreal Place Condo/Townhouse $165,500
Chili 219 Chestnut Ridge Road Single-Family $114,000
Chili 21 Pleasant View Drive Single-Family $112,000
Chili 1505 Westside Drive Single-Family $83,000
Gates 3 Jennifer Circle Single-Family $134,000
Gates 9 Lucena Drive Single-Family $129,000
Gates 54 Elder Street Single-Family $120,000
Greece 52 Dorsey Road Single-Family $82,000
Henrietta 43 Kinglet Drive Single-Family $235,000
Henrietta 6 Sundew Lane Single-Family $145,000
Irondequoit 2661 Titus Avenue Extension Single-Family $97,000
Ogden 197 Ogden Center Road Single-Family $133,000
Palmyra 1446 Hammond Road Single-Family $200,000
Perinton 42 Sunset Trail Single-Family $210,900
Rochester 115 Canterbury Road Single-Family $247,500
Scottsville Village 545 North Road Single-Family $117,000
Walworth 3591 Walworth Road Single-Family $101,000
Webster 807 County Line Road Single-Family $129,900
Phone: 585.698.2052
Cell: 585.474.3050
Fax: 585.334.1194
Henrietta Office
Send Email
Send Text Message
Henrietta Office
2920 East Henrietta Rd
Henrietta, NY  14467
Charlene Lally, Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

See Us On Facebook Follow us on Twitter See us on LinkedIn See Us on YouTube Red our blog
Our Sponsors
Questions/Comments | Website Feedback | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Site Map
© 1995-2017 Nothnagle REALTORS® Rochester, New York
Website developed and hosted by Independent Broker Advantage Systems, LLC